How insurance agents can win new Chicago businesses
For Insurance agents · ShingleList guide
A business that just got its Chicago license is about to need general liability, property, workers' comp and often commercial auto. The agent who reaches the owner first, with something useful, usually wins the policy.
1. Know which new businesses need coverage fastest
Restaurants and food businesses, contractors, childcare providers, auto shops and new trucking companies tend to have the most urgent insurance needs. Some license types come with insurance requirements, and landlords often ask for a certificate before move-in. Start your day with those categories.
2. Call within the first week
New owners make most of their setup decisions in the first days after licensing: bank accounts, payroll, insurance. A call in week one is a helpful introduction. A call in month six is just another sales call.
3. Lead with something useful, not a quote request
- Offer a quick checklist of coverages their license type usually needs.
- Mention certificate-of-insurance turnaround if they're signing a lease.
- For restaurants, ask about liquor liability and equipment breakdown.
- For trucking companies, ask about their filing and authority timeline.
4. Keep it compliant
Business contact data from public records is fair to use, but you still need to follow the Do-Not-Call rules for phone calls and CAN-SPAM for email: identify yourself, include your address, and honor opt-outs.
5. Make it a daily habit
The agents who win new businesses don't do it with a big monthly push. They work a short list every morning. ShingleList's daily email starts with a “call these 5 today” shortlist for exactly that reason.
See every new business in Chicago, with owner names and phone numbers, delivered by 7 AM every weekday.